top of page

Insurance Companies and Car Repairs: What You Need to Know

Accidents happen. When they do, most of us rely on insurance to cover the damage. But there's a lot more happening behind the scenes than you may realize. Here's the inside scoop on what goes on between insurance companies and car repair shops and how it can affect you as a consumer.

Insurance Companies and Car Repairs

1. Cost-Cutting Tactics

Insurance companies are businesses, and like all businesses, they're interested in maximizing their profits. This means they may use tactics to save money on car repairs, which can affect the quality of the work you receive.

How it impacts you: By encouraging repair shops to use cheaper parts or rush through jobs, insurance companies may be compromising the quality of your repairs. This can lead to further issues down the road, like poor performance, additional repairs, and even potential safety hazards. You could end up paying more out of pocket in the long run due to these substandard repairs.

2. High Score, Low Service

Insurance companies often rate repair shops based on specific metrics, such as speed of service or cost-effectiveness. However, these scores can sometimes be misleading. A shop might receive high scores for completing jobs quickly, but they might be sacrificing quality for speed.

How it impacts you: Quick repairs might seem like a good thing, but not if they're done hastily. You could end up with a car that breaks down sooner or needs more frequent repairs. This could affect your safety and end up costing you more money in the long term.

3. Power Imbalances

Insurance companies hold a significant amount of power over repair shops. They can influence where their clients go for repairs or even remove shops from their network if they don't comply with their demands. This can put repair shops in a tough spot, forcing them to prioritize the insurance company's interests over their customers.

How it impacts you: Repair shops may feel pressured to cut corners to stay in the insurance company's good graces. This could result in subpar repairs, leaving you with a car that's not as safe or reliable as it should be.

4. Behind-the-Scenes Efforts

Organizations like SAMBRA are working to improve relationships between insurers and repair shops, with the aim of increasing transparency and fairness in the industry. However, the success of these efforts has been mixed in the past.

How it impacts you: While it's good to see organizations advocating for better practices, you shouldn't rely on the industry to have your best interests at heart. It's essential to do your research, ask questions, and ensure you're getting the best quality repairs for your money.

5. The Right to Choose

It's important to know that you have the right to choose where your car is repaired. Your insurance company may suggest or even insist on specific shops, but the choice ultimately lies with you.

How it impacts you: Don't feel pressured to go to a repair shop that your insurance company recommends. Do your research and choose a shop that has a reputation for high-quality work and excellent customer service.

6. Future Developments

There's hope that the automotive repair industry can become more transparent and fair for consumers. With increased consumer awareness, organizations working on advocacy, and potential regulation, the industry could become more balanced.

How it impacts you: As a consumer, you have a voice. Speak up about your experiences and demand fairness and transparency. Support organizations and regulations that aim to improve the industry and hold insurance companies and repair shops accountable for providing high-quality service.


Car repairs can be stressful, but knowing what to look out for can help you get the best service for your money. Stay informed, ask questions, and advocate for a more transparent and fair industry. Your safety, wallet, and peace of mind will thank you.

38 views0 comments


bottom of page